Dante Labs is offering a whole genomes test for $199 this week as an early Black Friday special.
Please note that just as I was getting ready to push the publish button on this article, Veritas Genetics also jumped on the whole sequencing bandwagon for $199 for the first 1000 testers Nov. 19 and 20th. In this article, I discuss the Dante Labs test. I have NOT reviewed Veritas, their test nor terms, so the same cautions discussed below apply to them and any other company offering whole genome sequencing. The Veritas link is here.
Update – Veritas provides the VCF file for an additional $99, but does not provide FASTQ or BAM files, per their Tweet to me.
I have no affiliation with either company.
$199 (US) is actually a great price for a whole genome test, but before you click and purchase, there are some things you need to know about whole genome sequencing (WGS) and what it can and can’t do for you. Or maybe better stated, what you’ll have to do with your own results before you can utilize the information for genealogical purposes.
The four questions you need to ask yourself are:
- Why do you want to consider whole genome testing?
- What question(s) are you trying to answer?
- What information do you seek?
- What is your testing goal?
I’m going to say this once now, and I’ll say it again at the end of the article.
Whole genome sequencing tests are NOT A REPLACEMENT FOR GENEALOGICAL DNA TESTS for mitochondrial, Y or autosomal testing. Whole genome sequencing is not a genealogy magic bullet.
There are both pros and cons of this type of purchase, as with most everything. Whole genome tests are for the most experienced and technically savvy genetic genealogists who understand both working with genetics and this field well, who have already taken the vendors’ genealogy tests and are already in the Y, mitochondrial and autosomal comparison data bases.
If that’s you or you’re interested in medical information, you might want to consider a whole genome test.
Let’s start with some basics.
What Is Whole Genome Sequencing?
Whole Genome Sequencing will sequence most of your genome. Keep in mind that humans are more than 99% identical, so the only portions that you’ll care about either medically or genealogically are the portions that differ or tend to mutate. Comparing regions where you match everyone else tells you exactly nothing at all.
Exome Sequencing – A Subset of Whole Genome
Exome sequencing, a subset of whole genome sequencing is utilized for medical testing. The Exome is the region identified as the portions most likely to mutate and that hold medically relevant information. You can read about the benefits and challenges of exome testing here.
I have had my Exome sequenced twice, once at Helix and once at Genos, now owned by NantOmics. Currently, NantOmics does not have a customer sign-in and has acquired my DNA sequence as part of the absorption of Genos. I’ll be writing about that separately. There is always some level of consumer risk in dealing with a startup.
Helix sequences your Exome (plus) so that you can order a variety of DNA based or personally themed products from their marketplace, although I’m not convinced about the utility of even the legitimacy of some of the available tests, such as the “Wine Explorer.”
On the other hand, the world-class The National Geographic Society’s Genographic Project now utilizes Helix for their testing, as does Spencer Well’s company, Insitome.
You can also pay to download your Exome sequence data separately for $499.
Autosomal Testing for Genealogy
Both whole genome and Exome testing are autosomal testing, meaning that they test chromosomes 1-22 (as opposed to Y and mitochondrial DNA) but the number of autosomal locations varies vastly between the various types of tests.
The locations selected by the genealogy testing companies are a subset of both the whole genome and the Exome. The different vendors that compare your DNA for genealogy generally utilize between 600,000 and 900,000 chip-specific locations that they have selected as being inclined to mutate – meaning that we can obtain genealogically relevant information from those mutations.
Some vendors (for example, 23andMe and Ancestry) also include some medical SNPs (single nucleotide polymorphisms) on their chips, as both have formed medical research alliances with various companies.
Whole genome and Exome sequencing includes these same locations, BUT, the whole genome providers don’t compare the files to other testers nor reduce the files to the locations useful for genealogical comparisons. In other words, they don’t create upload files for you.
The following chart is not to scale, but is meant to convey the concept that the Exome is a subset of the whole genome, and the autosomal vendors’ selected SNPs, although not the same between the companies, are all subsets of the Exome and full genome.
I have not had my whole genome sequenced because I have seen no purpose for doing so, outside of curiosity.
This is NOT to imply that you shouldn’t. However, here are some things to think about.
Whole Genome Sequencing Questions
Coverage – Medical grade coverage is considered to be 30X, meaning an average of 30 scans of every targeted location in your genome. Some will have more and some will have less. This means that your DNA is scanned thirty different times to minimize errors. If a read error happens once or twice, it’s unlikely that the same error will happen several more times. You can read about coverage here and here.
Here’s an example where the read length of Read 1 is 18, and the depth of the location shown in light blue is 4, meaning 4 actual reads were obtained. If the goal was 30X, then this result would be very poor. If the goal was 4X then this location is a high quality result for a 4X read.
In the above example, if the reference value, meaning the value at the light blue location for most people is T, then 4 instances of a T means you don’t have a mutation. On the other hand, if T is not the reference value, then 4 instances of T means that a mutation has occurred in that location.
Dante Labs coverage information is provided from their webpage as follows:
Other vendors coverage values will differ, but you should always know what you are purchasing.
Ownership – Who owns your data? What happens to your DNA itself (the sample) and results (the files) under normal circumstances and if the company is sold. Typically, the assets of the company, meaning your information, are included during any acquisition.
Does the company “share, lease or sell” your information as an additional revenue stream with other entities? If so, do they ask your permission each and every time? Do they perform internal medical research and then sell the results? What, if anything, is your DNA going to be used for other than the purpose for which you purchased the test? What control do you exercise over that usage?
Read the terms and conditions carefully for every vendor before purchasing.
File Delivery – Three types of files are generated during a whole genome test.
The VCF (Variant Call Format) which details your locations that are different from the reference file. A reference file is the “normal” value for humans.
A FASTQ file which includes the nucleotide sequence along with a corresponding quality score. Mutations in a messy area or that are not consistent may not be “real” and are considered false positives.
The BAM (Binary Alignment Map) file is used for Y DNA SNP alignment. The output from a BAM file is displayed in Family Tree DNA’s Big Y browser for their customers. Are these files delivered to you? If so, how? Family Tree DNA delivers their Big Y DNA BAM files as free downloads.
Typically whole genome data is too large for a download, so it is sent on a disc drive to you. Dante provides this disc for BAM and FASTQ files for 59 Euro ($69 US) plus shipping. VCF files are available free, but if you’re going to order this product, it would be a shame not to receive everything available.
Version – Discoveries are still being made to the human genome. If you thought we’re all done with that, we’re not. As new regions are mapped successfully, the addresses for the rest change, and a new genomic map is created. Think of this as street addresses and a new cluster of houses is now inserted between existing houses. All of the houses are periodically renumbered.
Today, typically results are delivered in either of two versions: hg19(GRVH37) or hg38(GRCH38). What happens when the next hg (human genome) version is released?
When you test with a vendor who uses your data for comparison as a part of a product they offer, they must realign your data so that the comparison will work for all of their customers (think Family Tree DNA and GedMatch, for example), but a vendor who only offers the testing service has no motivation to realign your output file for you. You only pay for sequencing, not for any after-the-fact services.
Platform – Multiple sequencing platforms are available, and not all platforms are entirely compatible with other competing platforms. For example, the Illumina platform and chips may or may not be compatible with the Affymetrix platform (now Thermo Fisher) and chips. Ask about chip compatibility if you have a specific usage in mind before you purchase.
Location – Where is your DNA actually being sequenced? Are you comfortable having your DNA sent to that geographic location for processing? I’m personally fine with anyplace in either the US, Canada or most of Europe, but other locations maybe not so much. I’d have to evaluate the privacy policies, applicable laws, non-citizen recourse and track record of those countries.
Last but perhaps most important, what do you want to DO with this file/information?
What you receive from whole genome sequencing is files. What are you going to do with those files? How can you use them? What is your purpose or goal? How technically skilled are you, and how well do you understand what needs to be done to utilize those files?
A Specific Medical Question
If you have a particular question about a specific medical location, Dante allows you to ask the question as soon as you purchase, but you must know what question to ask as they note below.
You can click on their link to view their report on genetic diseases, but keep in mind, this is the disease you specifically ask about. You will very likely NOT be able to interpret this report without a genetic counselor or physician specializing in this field.
Take a look at both sample reports, here.
Health and Wellness in General
The Dante Labs Health and Wellness Report appears to be a collaborative effort with Sequencing.com and also appears to be included in the purchase price.
I uploaded both my Exome and my autosomal DNA results from the various testing companies (23andMe V3 and V4, Ancestry V1 and V2, Family Tree DNA, LivingDNA, DNA.Land) to Promethease for evaluation and there was very little difference between the health-related information returned based on my Exome data and the autosomal testing vendors. The difference is, of course, that the Exome coverage is much deeper (and therefore more reliable) because that test is a medical test, not a consumer genealogy test and more locations are covered. Whole genome testing would be more complete.
I wrote about Promethease here and here. Promethease does accept VCF files from various vendors who provide whole genome testing.
None of these tests are designed or meant for medical interpretation by non-professionals.
If you plan to test with the idea that should your physician need a genetics test, you’re already ahead of the curve, don’t be so sure. It’s likely that your physician will want a genetics test using the latest technology, from their own lab, where they understand the quality measures in place as well as how the data is presented to them. They are unlikely to accept a test from any other source. I know, because I’ve already had this experience.
The power of DNA testing for genealogy is comparing your data to others. Testing in isolation is not useful.
Mitochondrial DNA – I can’t tell for sure based on the sample reports, but it appears that you receive your full sequence haplogroup and probably your mutations as well from Dante. They don’t say which version of mitochondrial DNA they utilize.
However, without the ability to compare to other testers in a database, what genealogical benefit can you derive from this information?
Furthermore, mitochondrial DNA also has “versions,” and converting from an older to a newer version is anything but trivial. Haplogroups are renamed and branches sawed from one part of the mitochondrial haplotree and grafted onto another. A testing (only) vendor that does not provide comparisons has absolutely no reason to update your results and can’t be expected to do so. V17 is the current build, released in February 2016, with the earlier version history here.
Family Tree DNA is the only vendor who tests your full sequence mitochondrial DNA, compares it to other testers and updates your results when a new version is released. You can read more about this process, here and how to work with mtDNA results here.
Y DNA – Dante Labs provides BAM files, but other whole genome sequencers may not. Check before you purchase if you are interested in Y DNA. Again, you’ll need to be able to analyze the results and submit them for comparison. If you are not capable of doing that, you’ll need to pay a third party like either YFull or FGS (Full Genome Sequencing) or take the Big Y test at Family Tree DNA who has the largest Y Database worldwide and compares results.
Typically whole genome testers are looking for Y DNA SNPs, not STR values in BAM files. STR (short tandem repeat) values are the results that you receive when you purchase the 37, 67 or 111 tests at Family Tree DNA, as compared to the Big Y test which provides you with SNPs in order to resolve your haplogroup at the most granular level possible. You can read about the difference between SNPs and STRs here.
As with SNP data, you’ll need outside assistance to extract your STR information from the whole genome sequence information, none of which will be able to be compared with the testers in the Family Tree DNA data base. There is also an issue of copy-count standardization between vendors.
You can read about how to work with STR results and matches here and Big Y results here.
Autosomal DNA – None of the major providers that accept transfers (MyHeritage, Family Tree DNA, GedMatch) accept whole genome files. You would need to find a methodology of reducing the files from the whole genome to the autosomal SNPs accepted by the various vendors. If the vendors adopt the digital signature technology recently proposed in this paper by Yaniv Erlich et al to prevent “spoofed files,” modified files won’t be accepted by vendors.
Whole genome testing, in general, will and won’t provide you with the following:
|Desired Feature||Whole Genome Testing|
|Mitochondrial DNA||Presumed full haplogroup and mutations provided, but no ability for comparison to other testers. Upload to Family Tree DNA, the only vendor doing comparisons not available.|
|Y DNA||Presume Y chromosome mostly covered, but limited ability for comparison to other testers for either SNPs or STRs. Must utilize either YFull or FGS for SNP/STR analysis. Upload to Family Tree DNA, the vendor with the largest data base not available when testing elsewhere.|
|Autosomal DNA for genealogy||Presume all SNPs covered, but file output needs to be reduced to SNPs offered/processed by vendors accepting transfers (Family Tree DNA, MyHeritage, GedMatch) and converted to their file formats. Modified files may not be accepted in the future.|
|Medical (consumer interest)||Accuracy is a factor of targeted coverage rate and depth of actual reads. Whole genome vendors may or may not provide any analysis or reports. Dante does but for limited number of conditions. Promethease accepts VCF files from vendors and provides more.|
|Medical (physician accepted)||Physician is likely to order a medical genetics test through their own institution. Physicians may not be willing to risk a misdiagnosis due to a factor outside of their control such as an incompatible human genome version.|
|Files||VCF, FASTQ and BAM may or may not be included with results, and may or may not be free.|
|Coverage||Coverage and depth may or may not be adequate. Multiple extractions (from multiple samples) may or may not be included with the initial purchase (if needed) or may be limited. Ask.|
|Updates||Vendors who offer sequencing as a part of a products that include comparison to other testers will update your results version to the current reference version, such as hg38 and mitochondrial V17. Others do not, nor can they be expected to provide that service.|
|Version||Inquire as to the human genome (hg) version or versions available to you, and which version(s) are acceptable to the third party vendors you wish to utilize. When the next version of the human genome is released, your file will no longer be compatible because WGS vendors are offering sequencing only, not results comparisons to databases for genealogy.|
|Ownership/Usage||Who owns your sample? What will it be utilized for, other than the service you ordered, by whom and for what purposes? Will you we able to authorize or decline each usage?|
|Location||Where geographically is your DNA actually being sequenced and stored? What happens to your actual DNA sample itself and the resulting files? This may not be the location where you return your swab kit.|
The Question – Will I Order?
The bottom line is that if you are a genealogist, seeking genetic information for genealogical purposes, you’re much better off to test with the standard and well know genealogy vendors who offer compatibility and comparisons to other testers.
If you are a pioneer in this field, have the technical ability required to make use of a whole genome test and are willing to push the envelope, then perhaps whole genome sequencing is for you.
I am considering ordering the Dante Labs whole genome test out of simple curiosity and to upload to Promethease to determine if the whole genome test provides me with something potentially medically relevant (positive or negative) that autosomal and Exome testing did not.
I’m truly undecided. Somehow, I’m having trouble parting with the $199 plus $69 (hard drive delivery by request when ordering) plus shipping for this limited functionality. If I was a novice genetic genealogist or was not a technology expert, I would definitely NOT order this test for the reasons mentioned above.
A whole genome test is not in any way a genealogical replacement for a full sequence mitochondrial test, a Y STR test, a Y SNP test or an autosomal test along with respective comparison(s) in the data bases of vendors who don’t allow uploads for these various functions.
The simple fact that 30X whole genome testing is available for $199 plus $69 plus shipping is amazing, given that 15 years ago that same test cost 2.7 billion dollars. However, it’s still not the magic bullet for genealogy – at least, not yet.
Today, the necessary integration simply doesn’t exist. You pay the genealogy vendors not just for the basic sequencing, but for the additional matching and maintenance of their data bases, not to mention the upgrading of your sequence as needed over time.
If I had to choose between spending the money for the WGS test or taking the genealogy tests, hands down, I’d take the genealogy tests because of the comparisons available. Comparison and collaboration is absolutely crucial for genealogy. A raw data file buys me nothing genealogically.
If I had not previously taken an Exome test, I would order this test in order to obtain the free Dante Health and Wellness Report which provides limited reporting and to upload my raw data file to Promethease. The price is certainly right.
However, keep in mind that once you view health information, you cannot un-see it, so be sure you do really want to know.
What do you plan to do? Are you going to order a whole genome test?
I receive a small contribution when you click on some (but not all) of the links to vendors in my articles. This does NOT increase the price you pay but helps me to keep the lights on and this informational blog free for everyone. Please click on the links in the articles or to the vendors below if you are purchasing products or DNA testing.
Thank you so much.
DNA Purchases and Free Transfers
- Family Tree DNA
- MyHeritage DNA only
- MyHeritage DNA plus Health
- MyHeritage FREE DNA file upload
- 23andMe Ancestry
- 23andMe Ancestry Plus Health
- Legacy Tree Genealogists for genealogy research
Great summary and breakdown of pros and cons. Well written. Thanks so much for the thorough evaluation. Now, how about the hotter topic of artifact testing,which is the really exciting news on the cutting edge.
We are waiting for results from the early tests.
Thanks Roberta- also considering! FYI, SNPedia mentioned problems using Promethease with Dante’s output and limitations with data from Veritas. https://www.snpedia.com/index.php/Testing
As always, another great explanatory article! Just a couple of comments.
I found your statement that NantOmics (who bought Genos) doesn’t offer login. I can still login to view my Genos results at https://genos.co/
Also, if I read correctly, you state that Dante charges for shipping. When I ordered yesterday there was no charge for shipping. I paid $199 total per test for 3 test kits. In a seperate order I bought the $69 data hard drive and there was no shipping charged on that order either.
I heard from NantOmics today, and they provided the login link. My previous links didn’t work and weren’t forwarded. They also said they retain their commitment to not sharing your DNA unless you approve first.
The commentary about shipping was directly from Dante and the shipping wasn’t for the test, but was when the hard drive ships. Maybe it will be charged at that time. I don’t think shipping is going to make or break the deal for me.
I was surprised to discover today that Veritas charges $99 for the VCF file and does not provide either the FASTQ nor the BAM.
I was reviewing both offerings before deciding, but that’s a significant difference for something that requires little to no effort on Veritas’ part. Especially at this pricepoint, that might be a dealbreaker for me.
Great blog, Roberta, thanks.
I can still login to Genos.co with no problem.
Do you see (or foresee) any issues with NantOmics now owning Genos?
I heard back from them and they indicate they are respecting the Genos commitment. I have not been able to review everything thoroughly yet.
I emailed Dante Labs as I noticed in their literature they have “lab partners”. As far as I could tell they outsourced the WGS test to somebody else. I emailed info ID at Dante and they responded that this test was being processed by “BGI”.
This is a big Chinese government sponsored lab.
I don’t know how they can be EU GDPR compliant, but whatever.
I wondered the same thing when I saw that.
I have Dantelabs complete WES results: 2 VCFs (SNPs & INDELs), 1 BAM (OEF is trucated although I can read full mtDNA and chr1 in Hg19) and 2 paired FASTQ files (raw diamonds, I made new BAMs for every chromosome in GRCh37 and some chroms in GRCh38). Datelabs VCFs have only 120,000 loci and my new big WES BCF have about 25,000,000 loci (5 million after filtering).
About my WGS: I have only VCF results in this moment (waiting for hard drive since September!). Comparing my big WES, 23andme v4 raw data and WGS snp.VCF (3.5M variants) about 7,000 SNPs detected by Dantelabs in their WES snp.VCF are not detected in my new BAMs nor lab WGS snp.VCF
I uploaded to Promethease WGS snp.VCF both big WES VCF (snps&indels) getting 19,000 Snpedia genos. I think results are very accurate.
Roberta, I was informed on another forum that the Dante/BGI China WGS limitation of 100 base pairs makes a difference versus the way Big Y or FGC do 150 base pairs read lengths.
Even though from a stand-alone perspective the WGS coverage of Big Y regions looks good, SNPs will be missed by shortcutting the read length. That means the Dante/BGI WGS offering can not compared like for like with either Big Y or FGC Elite.
That’s a problem in a phylogenetic analysis. The Dante tested is more for health and other things, not genealogy support.
The current Y NGS matching database is essentially almost totally Big Y based with some FGC Elite too.
This what I interpret from the discussion. Are you hearing otherwise or can you clarify?
Do you think their Whole GenomeZ for $899 is worth it?
Whether you want to purchase a while genome from anyone has to do with what you want to do with it.
Roberta, Our family members have: yDNA test results @ ftdna (2), autosomal tests from 3 companies (12 + results from one family for bone marrow matches), and one mtdna test from ftdna. Several data sample results have been uploaded to gedmatch.
The one WGS sample with Dante Labs has just arrived at their location. I am guessing 6-8 weeks for processing.
Are there downloadable apps to manipulate the data from Dante Labs?
What else are we missing?
No, there is nothing straightforward for the Dante results. What was your goal in ordering?
Roberta, the link to Promethease currently comes up as a potential threat:
Firefox detected a potential security threat and did not continue to promethease.com. If you visit this site, attackers could try to steal information like your passwords, emails, or credit card details. The issue is most likely with the website, and there is nothing you can do to resolve it.
Have you seen this? I am hesitant to go there although you and ISOGG seem to have faith in it.
Have you had any experience with Sequencing.com?
I haven’t had any issues and Symantec isn’t having a problem. I gave not used Sequencing.
I used Chrome and it worked fine. Thank you.
That’s what I use.
Excellent article. Thank you. I was able to understand a lot!
My question: I have done WGS at Dante Labs and imported the BAM (100GB) file in sequencing.com. The import in Promethease is still pending. I would like to be able to explore “my own” configuration of all known SNPs up to date. For example if I’m reading an article that mentiones rs10994415, rs1006737 and other SNPs, I expect to copy-paste it in sequencing selecting the “Variant” column and to see my genotype. However some SNPs are present, but others aren’t.
What am I missing? Initially I had a .VCF.GZ file which was supposed to be the “difference” between my genes with the reference genome. My assumption was that the missing SNPs were missing, because they were the same as the reference genome and hence not shown in sequencing/promethease. That’s why I requested the BAM file, expecting it to be “my own differences aligned with the reference genome”, so all possible SNPs would be included.
Please excuse my lack of knowledge. I’m trying to deal with something out of my expertise domain and I’m unable to understand what’s going on for weeks.
I have no idea.