At the 2016 Family Tree DNA 12th Annual International Conference on Genetic Genealogy held in Houston, Texas in November, I was honored to present Lifetime Achievement Awards to both Bennett Greenspan and Max Blankfeld from the genetic genealogy community in the form of DNA double helix quilts.
I chose quilts as awards because quilts embody the deep cross-cultural symbolism of family, of caring and of warmth. Quilts can be utilitarian, artistic, or both – hung on the wall or napped under. They descend to the next generation, just like our DNA. These unique quilts, and yes, there are two, show the easily recognizable double helix strands, but also suggest the mystery of the unknown and yet to be discovered. Quilts seemed the perfect medium.
I must admit, I agonized for weeks about what I was going to say, and months about the DNA quilts themselves. Ok, I had a bit of analysis paralysis having to do with the quilt design and construction, but with the deadline of the approaching conference looming months, then weeks away, I kicked into overdrive to finish the quilts.
But then, the most difficult part – what to say to and about these amazing humans. I’ve been involved in public speaking for the past 30+ years, and I’m very comfortable – except not this time. This presentation was about a subject very close to my heart – and about the men who have provided all genetic genealogists with the opportunities we have today.
Before I share what I said, I would like to thank my co-conspirators:
- Janine Cloud
- Katherine Borges
- Nora Probasco
- Linda Magellan
- Jim Brewster
Katherine, Nora and Linda have all been to all 12 of the conferences and are fellow quilters. Linda is making labels for their quilts to affix to the back so they will never forget – although I doubt there is much possibility of that happening. Jim Brewster will sew the labels to the backs of the quilts when Linda mails the labels to Texas.
Max and Bennett are very humble men and I know they were embarrassed and amazingly enough, for those of us who are fortunate enough to know then – they were also pretty much speechless. At least for a couple minutes!
I’d like to take this opportunity to share the awards presentation with you. I’ve taken the liberty of added a few photos.
Many people don’t know Max and Bennett personally, nor do they know the history of genetic genealogy and direct to consumer DNA testing. I hope this presentation both honors Max and Bennett, and serves to educate about the humble beginnings of genetic genealogy.
I’m honored to present two Lifetime Achievement Awards today. Yes, there has been a conspiracy afoot. You have no idea how difficult it is to sneak onto a conference agenda. Thank you Janine Cloud. Additional co-conspirators are Katherine Borges, Nora Probasco and Linda Magellan, three people who have attended every conference since the beginning.
Let’s talk about the beginning.
Most everyone knows the story about Bennett Greenspan’s first retirement in 1999.
Bennett tried to retire, but managed to get underfoot at home, and his wife in essence threw him out of the house. She told him she didn’t much care WHAT he did, but he had to find SOMETHING to do, SOMEPLACE ELSE.
Now, knowing that Bennett is a genealogist, I’m betting that living in Houston, he went to the Clayton Library every day and assured his wife he was busy looking for a new career. He found it alright, or maybe it found him.
Someplace, at the Clayton Library or elsewhere, Bennett was thinking about how to prove that men with a common surname were or were not descended from a common ancestral line. Were they related? Bennett knew just enough about science to know that if he could find a way to test their Y chromosomes, and they descended from a common paternal ancestor, their Y DNA should match. Sometimes a little knowledge is a dangerous thing!
Bennett began a search to find a scientist that could and would run that one Y DNA test for him. As it turns out, could and would were two entirely different matters. Bennett found Dr. Michael Hammer at the University of Arizona who runs the Hammer Lab that specializes in human evolutionary genetics.
Dr. Hammer could, but would he?
Bennett mentions talking to Dr. Hammer on the phone several times. Dr. Hammer mentions that Bennett camped out in his office and wouldn’t leave. However persistent Bennett was or wasn’t, in person or otherwise, we should all be incredibly grateful for his tenacity, because purely in self-defense, Dr. Hammer agreed to do the test – just that one test.
However, Dr. Hammer made a fateful throwaway comment as Bennett was on the way out the door. He said, “Someone should start a business doing this. You crazy genealogists ask me about this ALL THE TIME.”
Talk about what never to say to a bored entrepreneur. That “all the time” statement echoed and rolled around in Bennett’s head. “All the time…all the time.”
Now, I don’t know exactly what happened next, but Bennett and Max were already business partners in another endeavor, and I’d bet the next conversation went something like this:
“Max – I’ve got an idea….”
Followed by a brief discussion and then:
“Bennett, are you crazy? No one will ever buy that?”
Like I said, I wasn’t there – but I’m really glad Bennett was a bit crazy – because so are the rest of us genealogists – as is proven by the size and magnitude of the genetic genealogy industry today.
The fledgling business, Family Tree DNA, was founded with Dr. Hammer’s lab doing the testing.
Fast forward a few months to July 14, 2000.
Cousin Doug Mumma, who, by the way, I didn’t know was a cousin until several years later thanks to a Family Finder test, called Family Tree DNA and talked to Bennett about Y DNA testing several Mumma men and men with similar surnames to see if they descended from a common ancestor. If Bennett was crazy wanting Y DNA testing, he is accompanied by a whole lot of other genealogists. Perhaps it’s genetic.
Bennett agreed to form a project for Doug and Doug agreed to commit to purchase 20 kits. Doug’s first kit in the Mumma Surname Project was kit M-01 and by the time he was ready to purchase project kit number 21, the M was gone from the kit designation, and he purchased kit number 72.
Fast forward another few months.
I had tested my mitochondrial DNA with Oxford Ancestors and for something like $900 discovered that I was the daughter of Jasmine, one of the seven daughters of Eve. I received a one page diagram with a gold star placed on the letter J. My fascination with the science of genetic genealogy had begun.
One of my cousins mentioned that some company in Texas was doing DNA testing on men for the Y chromosome for genealogy. I was just sure this was some kind of scam, because I figured if that could be done, Oxford Ancestors would be offering that too – and they weren’t.
I found the phone number for Family Tree DNA, called and left a message.
Later that night, about 9:30, my phone rang and it was Bennett Greenspan returning my call – the President of Family Tree DNA.
Little did I know, at that time, that the office consisted of Bennett’s cell phone.
We talked for an hour. I explained to Bennett that I had tested for mitochondrial DNA and asked about the Y DNA testing. Bennett described what Family Tree DNA was doing with testing and projects, convincing me it was not a scam after all. While I certainly understood the genetic basis of how Y DNA testing worked, I had not seen the website, or the software, and I was concerned about explaining how matching worked on the site between different men in a project.
Bennett said something fateful, which I’m sure he’s regretting right about now. He said, “Don’t worry – I’ll help you.”
With that, I committed to purchase 5 kits and he committed to create the Estes surname project, and help me if I needed assistance. I quickly found 5 willing Estes genealogists who desperately wanted to know if they descended from a common Estes progenitor. The Estes DNA project was formed.
In mid-December 2002, I purchased kit 6656. Kits were selling at the incredible rate of about 2000 a year!
The DNA results were amazing and full of potential for every ancestral line. I quickly became an advocate of genetic genealogy, although Rootsweb wouldn’t let us discuss DNA testing on the boards and lists, like it was some sort of pariah. DNA proved and disproved genealogy, myths and oral history – which bothered some folks immensely.
By 2004, genetic genealogy was growing and so was the interest in this field. Around the beginning of 2004, kit 17,000 was sold and twelve months later, on New Year’s Eve, kit 30,244 was sold. Participation in genetic genealogy nearly doubled in 2004 and in two years, it had quadrupled. By now, kits were selling at just under 2000 per month.
November 2004 saw the first conference sponsored by Family Tree DNA in Houston which lasted only one day. The excitement in the community was palpable. Not only were we excited about the conference itself, and learning, but by meeting each other face to face.
In April of 2005, Family Tree DNA made the announcement that they had teamed with the National Geographic Society and the Genographic Project was launched. This liaison was the turning point that legitimized DNA testing to the rest of the world. People began to see DNA testing featured in the iconic magazine with the yellow cover and no one wondered anymore if we were just plain crazy.
In November 2005, the second Family Tree DNA Genetic Genealogy conference, which became the second annual conference, was held in Washington DC at the headquarters of the National Geographic Society.
This conference was extra exciting because of the location and the implications for genetic genealogy. We had come of age. The conference was held in the “Explorers Hall.” We were recognized as explorers too in this brave new genetic world.
My husband and I stayed at a hotel called The Helix in Washington, within walking distance to the National Geographic building. On the morning of the conference, we left the hotel for the 5-minute walk to Nat Geo. In front of us, maybe 30 feet, were Max and Bennett, briskly walking and chatting. We continued behind them, not wanting to interrupt. In those few minutes, I remember distinctly thinking that I was literally watching history being made by the two men in front of me. Little did I know exactly how true that was and what the future held.
On New Year’s Eve, 2005, I purchased kit 50,000. Of course, I had to purchase about 10 kits to manage to get kit 50,000, right at midnight. Unbeknownst to me, the Genographic Project had sold nearly 100,000 kits. Genetic genealogy had passed silently from its infancy.
Every year since then, more history has unfolded.
Few people get the opportunity to shape the future.
Few people get the opportunity to directly affect more than a few lives – in this case, millions.
Few people get the opportunity to found not just a business, but an industry that will continue to provide information and answers long after we are nothing more than genealogical memories.
Few people get to chart the course of history.
Yes, I’m talking about Max and Bennett.
No, they don’t know anything about this.
About this time, Bennett apparently suspected not only that the awards might be for he and Max, but also realized that he had been “had.” Janine Cloud, was the person with the difficult task of making sure that Bennett and Max were in the room during this time, in addition to providing a disguised space on the agenda for these awards.
This is the look on Bennett’s face when he realized and looked at Janine.
Followed by this photo. Janine is standing behind Bennett.
Max, however, didn’t suspect, because he was busy. I can just hear Bennett, “Pssst, Max…..”
So, until now, Max probably really doesn’t know exactly what I said up to this point.
Max and Bennett not only founded the genetic genealogy industry, they have maintained a leadership position within that industry while others perished. They have an entire series of firsts attributed to them, but if I took time to list them all, we would be here all day.
What I will say is that they have created this industry with the utmost integrity and with their eye to the consumer. One example stands out.
I was standing at a conference some years ago when a man asked Bennett about backbone SNP testing. Bennett asked him which haplogroup. The man answered, then Bennett told him not to spend his money on that test for that haplogroup, because he wasn’t likely to learn anything he didn’t already know.
Being a project administrator, I was surprised at Bennett’s response. I spoke with Bennett and he said he never wanted his customers to feel like they didn’t receive value for their money. That’s not something one would expect to hear from the mouth of a businessman. But that is Bennett.
Integrity has been the guiding principle and the foundation of Family Tree DNA and remains so today.
Max and Bennett have given us what is arguably the single most valuable tool for genealogists – ever – not to mention those searching for their birth family.
Francis Crick and James Watson discovered DNA in 1953, but it would be another 47 years before Bennett Greenspan and Max Blankfeld gave us the rosetta stone so that “the rest of us” can understand our DNA and how it’s relevant to our own lives – and those of our ancestors. That vision in 1999 and the fledgling startup company in 2000 was the cornerstone of the DTC, direct to consumer, DNA industry today.
I am honored to present Max and Bennett with special Lifetime Achievement Awards – that are – well – a bit different from any other lifetime achievement award. But then, they are unique so their awards should be as well.
I am asking Katherine Borges, Linda Magellan and Nora Probasco to help present these awards on behalf of the genetic genealogy community. All 3 have attended all of the conferences.
Katherine Borges closed the presentation with the following quote by Wilferd Peterson.
Walk with the Dreamers,
The Successful people with their heads in the clouds and their feet on the ground,
Let their Spirit ignite a fire within you to leave this world better than when you found it.
We stand on the shoulders of giants.
Thank you Max and Bennett for inviting and allowing us to walk with you on this most fabulous journey. You are the wind beneath our wings.
What you can’t see in the photos is the standing ovation for Max and Bennett. People came up to me afterwards and thanked me, saying that they wanted to say those things, but couldn’t or didn’t know how.
At this point, we told Max and Bennett that they had to close their eyes. They are indeed trusting souls.
When they opened their eyes, I’m sure they didn’t know quite what to think. They were both looking to their left at first, and I think they thought there was one quilt.
I do love the looks on their faces. We wanted them to be surprised and joyful, and they clearly were.
They weren’t entirely speechless, but close.
Max said something short and gracious, then handed the microphone to Bennett and said , “Here Bennett, you say something.” The crowd laughed. Max and Bennett both handled the situation with the grace and dignity we have come to expect.
For those who would like to see a closeup, Katherine Borges took a nice picture.
I will be writing a separate article about the quilts themselves.
Family Tree DNA offers lab tours on the Monday following the conference, and I was able to take a photo of Max and Bennett in the office with the quilts. For those who don’t know, Gene by Gene is the parent company of Family Tree DNA.
I’m sure none of us, including Max and Bennett had any idea 16 years ago where this road would lead. It has been an amazing journey – a fantastic magic carpet ride!
I want to thank everyone who contributed in any way to these awards for Bennett and Max, including everyone who has bought tests and participated in DNA testing for genetic genealogy. Every time I thank Max, he always says, “No, thank YOU. We wouldn’t be here without you,” meaning the testing community. That’s Max, and I know he means it sincerely.
Not only was this a wonderful opportunity to honor the men who founded and anchor this industry and community, but also to celebrate individuals being able to participate in discovery on the forefront of the final frontier, the one within us. What Max and Bennett have provided is an opportunity beyond measure. I could never have dreamed a dream this big. I’m eternally grateful that they did.
Thank you, Max and Bennett, for everything you have done for genetic genealogy over the past 16 years, for founding Family Tree DNA, for projects and a wide variety of products, for embracing, including and encouraging genealogists, scientists and citizen scientists, and for providing continuing opportunities to unwrap the genetic gifts left to us by our ancestors.
I have struggled to find words big enough, strong enough and deep enough. I hope when you look at your quilts, you will simply feel our everlasting gratitude for how profoundly you have touched and irreversibly changed the lives of so many, one by one, in essence sewing many small stitches in the quilt of humanity.
Photos courtesy Jennifer Zinck, Jim Hollern, Katherine Borges, Janine Cloud, Jim Kvochick and ISOGG.
I receive a small contribution when you click on some of the links to vendors in my articles. This does NOT increase the price you pay but helps me to keep the lights on and this informational blog free for everyone. Please click on the links in the articles or to the vendors below if you are purchasing products or DNA testing.
Thank you so much.
DNA Purchases and Free Transfers
- Family Tree DNA
- MyHeritage DNA only
- MyHeritage DNA plus Health
- MyHeritage FREE DNA file upload
- 23andMe Ancestry
- 23andMe Ancestry Plus Health
- Legacy Tree Genealogists for genealogy research
Roberta, I am related to the Mumma family through the Akins of Petersburg, VA, Chesterfield and Henrico Counties. I am in the process of working on my genetic genealogy with a tutor, Terri Stern, but it is slow because I am 82, that’s past my sell-by-date but I have so much enjoyment bcz of the Genetic genealogy. Do you know of Akins in your tree? Occasionally, I see an Estes name in one of the gedmatch kits I am managing but I haven’t gotten there yet! Keep up the good work. It was running across your blog that got me into genetic genealogy. AND, quilting, too! Wonder Woman! I wonder who is going to make your quilt? Carol Aiken Preece firstname.lastname@example.org
I have been very fortunate that my quilt sisters (and quilt-brother too) have made me quilts and wall hangings over the years. One of my favorite curl-up quilts is my “coffee quilt” – and based on the name, I’m sure you can surmise why she made it for me. I don’t have Akins in my tree, that I know of. I am related to Doug through a Miller line. Keep up the good work and don’t give up. You never know what the next nugget to uncover will be:) And bless your tutor too!!!
It was an amazing moment and the quilts are absolutely gorgeous! I’m looking forward to the story about making them. You need to post a photo of the back side of the quilts, too.
You are obviously a quilter too, Nancy:)
No … not me! I made an apron in 7th grade and that’s about as far as my sewing ability goes. They are just so beautiful and I have no idea how it could possibly be done.
Your comment about the back is what made me think that. All quilters are always looking at the backs of quilts to see the quilting design – which – in this case is also a double helix. I’ll include that when I do the article.
I just thought the back was really pretty.
Not to minimize the awards and the recipients, but the design of those quilts is so far beyond imagination!!! You must be one of the most multi-talented people around, Roberta!
Thank you. Those quilts drove me crazy:) That’s my story anyway, and I’m sticking to it. I’m finishing a similar one for me and I’ll write the article and include all 3 after the holidays. Ironically, the kind of detail focus that is required for both hobbies is much the same, so while they are different, they aren’t entirely.
We like you crazy!
Well that’s good because I don’t know how to be anything else.
Your remarks were so gracious. You echoed the gratitude of many other genealogists not in attendance. Thank you for sharing the story.
What a wonderful post Roberta! The quilt is fantastic.
I hit post too quickly. I have a Roberta Estes on my match list…is it you? The name on my kit is Karen Brotherston Wirth
I have several kits under my name. If there is a middle name in parenthesis, it’s for someone else. Believe it or not, there is also another Roberta Estes. My e-mail address includes my name.
Fantastic Roberta!! We had all loved the DNA journey, even though I didn’t get to join the ride until 2010! Love the quilt too. Hope you are including a template in your next post!!
The article about the quilt itself will be after the holidays.
We’d all be nowhere if it weren’t for FamilyTreeDna. Kudos and gratitude are well deserved by Bennett and Max, no doubt. But FamilyTreeDNA would be nowhere without the selfless efforts of you, Roberta Estes, and others like you who spread the word and freely share the knowledge that helps us less scientific types to make sense of the jargon. A huge THANK YOU for all you do.
Roberta, Thank you for continuing to educate us all in the field of genealogy. You are a gifted writer and I have enjoyed reading your blog (which included a reference to my own Indiana Weinacht ancestors!) I have always wondered about the origin of dna/genetic genealogy. Thank you for all you do! Your quilts are a true work of art!
Thank you. I wouldn’t be one bit surprised if the Kirsch/Koehler and Weinacht families from Mutterstadt and surrounding villages are related.
Roberta, the quilts are absolutely gorgeous. Thank you for all that you do and for thinking of this well deserved tribute. I remember talking to Bennett several times when we first started a couple of projects and he was always so gracious and helpful.
Thank you for thanking him. I’m an early tester (4818) and I had actually tested with ancestry.com on 23 strings earlier in 2002. I bought a transfer kit from FTDNA and had to manually enter my data there. They ended up sending me a kit and redid the whole 25 string test for me for free. I asked them why they were doing it at the time and they replied they just wanted to make sure they I had the right data. I always thought that was wonderful.
Thanks to them after 14 years I finally nearly broke through my brick well despite an undocumented adoption in the 1850s and some poorly timed mutations in the last 2 generations.
The quilts are simply stunning. Thank you for so eloquently thanking two very special people in the world of genetic genealogy. And thank you for being a pioneer and dragging the rest of us along.
Great quilts! What a neat idea. I hope that in your post on the quilts you say a bit about the fabric choices–how you located all those science-related textiles. I know some are just out there to be found, but these days people are also designing their own fabric. (I keep planning to design some as a fundraiser for Dayton Area Rabbit Network.)
The problem is that many of the fabrics are out of print, and were at the time I made this. I found pieces of some by googling, but in other cases, I had to punt. So the fabrics may not be available. Now, with Spoonflower, it’s possible. I do like the ides of self-designing.
Out of print fabric, even! Impressive. Yeah, I bought a couple of books on fabric design and joined Spoonflower but need to take the time to really figure out what I’m doing.
If you design DNA fabric, PLEASE let me know. Yes, I’m a DNA and a fabric junkie, both.
I’ll keep that in mind, but I’m not planning any DNA designs–mainly I’m planning to work with some out of copyright imagery of animals. However, it looked to me like your co-presenters were wearing DNA fabric!
They were. I’d like to make myself a vest for next year.
You know, it occurs to me that Spoonflower is always doing design competitions. Suggest that they do one for DNA Day–that should produce some fun DNA-based fabrics!
How wonderful! I too wish to thank Max and Bennett, for without the new science of genetic genealogy which they have made possible, I never would have found out who my father was. God bless them both!
If history articles were gem stones, this blog would be a crown jewel. Thank you.
You are very kind. Thank you.
Pingback: 2016 Genetic Genealogy Retrospective | DNAeXplained – Genetic Genealogy
Pingback: Thankfulness Recipe | DNAeXplained – Genetic Genealogy